The Evolution of Amazon’s Marketplace: Understanding 1P vs 3P
You know what’s fascinating about Amazon? It started as a simple online bookstore, and now it’s basically the Death Star of retail (minus the whole planet-destroying thing). But here’s the thing – while everyone’s focused on Prime Day deals and same-day delivery, there’s this whole behind-the-scenes drama playing out between two distinct business models: 1P and 3P selling.
Think of it like this: Amazon’s marketplace is essentially two parallel universes existing simultaneously. In one universe (1P), you’re basically selling your soul (and inventory) directly to Amazon. In the other (3P), you’re more like an independent merchant setting up shop in Amazon’s infinite digital mall.
The Current State of 1P vs 3P on Amazon
Let’s drop some mind-bending numbers: Third-party sellers now account for about 60% of Amazon’s total sales. That’s roughly $300 billion in gross merchandise value. Remember when Amazon was just Jeff Bezos and some books in a garage? Yeah, we’ve come a long way.
Breaking Down the Amazon Vendor Central Universe
1P selling is like getting invited to an exclusive club – and Amazon’s the bouncer. Through Vendor Central, brands sell their products wholesale to Amazon, who then turns around and sells them to customers. It’s the digital equivalent of traditional retail relationships, just with more algorithms and less face-to-face negotiation.
Here’s what makes it interesting: When you’re a 1P seller, Amazon literally owns your inventory. They control pricing, they handle fulfillment, and they’re essentially the face of your brand to the customer. It’s like having a really powerful business partner who sometimes makes decisions you might not agree with.
The Wild West of Seller Central (3P)
3P selling, on the other hand, is more like running your own show within Amazon’s ecosystem. Through Seller Central, you maintain control over your inventory, pricing, and brand presence. It’s more hands-on, but with that comes more freedom and potentially higher margins.
Think of 3P as being a store owner in the world’s biggest shopping mall. You’re responsible for everything from inventory management to customer service, but you get to make all the key decisions about your business. For more insights on how sellers can grow their business on Amazon, check out this resource.
The Financial Tale of Two Models
Let’s talk money – because that’s what this is really about, right? With 1P, you’re looking at wholesale margins and longer payment terms (sometimes painfully long, like 60-90 days). Amazon’s purchasing team can be tougher than a New York landlord when it comes to negotiations.
3P sellers typically see higher margins but deal with various fees – referral fees, FBA fees if you’re using Amazon’s fulfillment, storage fees… it’s like death by a thousand paper cuts, except with more spreadsheets involved.
Control vs Convenience: The Eternal Struggle
Here’s where it gets really interesting. With 1P, you’re essentially trading control for convenience. Amazon handles everything post-purchase, but they also control your destiny on their platform. They can change prices at will, and if they decide to stop buying your product… well, good luck with that.
3P sellers maintain control but face more day-to-day operational challenges. It’s like choosing between being a passenger in a luxury car or driving your own vehicle. Sure, driving means more work, but at least you decide where you’re going and how to get there.
The Platform Battle: Vendor Central vs Seller Central
Let’s geek out about the platforms for a second. Vendor Central is like the Enterprise’s bridge – sophisticated but sometimes frustratingly rigid. Seller Central, meanwhile, is more like the Millennium Falcon – it might not look as pretty, but it’s more versatile and you can modify it to suit your needs.
Through Vendor Central, you’ll deal with purchase orders, charge-backs, and cooperative marketing agreements. It’s very corporate, very structured. Seller Central gives you direct access to your customers, real-time pricing control, and immediate feedback on your strategies.
Making the Choice: Which Universe Do You Want to Live In?
Here’s the thing about choosing between 1P and 3P – it’s not just about the money or the control. It’s about understanding your business’s DNA and what you want your relationship with Amazon to look like.
If you’re a larger brand with established wholesale channels and you prefer a hands-off approach, 1P might be your jam. You’ll sacrifice some control and margin, but you’ll gain Amazon’s operational expertise and the coveted “Ships from and sold by Amazon” badge. To dive deeper into the 1P vs 3P seller models, this guide provides comprehensive insights.
But if you’re more of a growth-focused brand that wants to maintain control over your destiny (and margins), 3P could be your path. Yes, it requires more work, but it also gives you the flexibility to pivot quickly and maintain direct relationships with your customers.
The Hybrid Approach: Having Your Cake and Eating It Too
Here’s a plot twist – some brands actually do both. They maintain a 1P relationship for their core products while experimenting with new items through 3P. It’s like being a double agent, but completely legal and actually pretty smart if you can manage the complexity.
The key is understanding that these models aren’t mutually exclusive. You can use them strategically to maximize your presence on Amazon while minimizing your risks. It’s all about finding the right balance for your specific situation.
The Future of Amazon’s Selling Models
Looking ahead, the landscape is constantly evolving. Amazon’s pushing more brands toward 3P, but they’re also introducing new tools and services that blur the lines between the two models. It’s like watching a retail version of convergent evolution.
The smart money is on staying flexible and understanding both models deeply enough to adapt as the market changes. Because in the end, success on Amazon isn’t just about picking the right model – it’s about being able to evolve with the platform.
👉👉 Create Photos, Videos & Optimized Content in minutes 👈👈
Related Articles:
- Understanding En Route to DHL Ecommerce or Awaiting Processing
- Why Instagram Music is Not Working: Common Issues and Fixes
Frequently Asked Questions
What is amazon walmart?
Amazon and Walmart are two of the largest retail giants in the world, both offering a vast range of products and services. Amazon primarily operates as an online marketplace, providing a platform for both first-party (1P) and third-party (3P) sellers. Walmart, while traditionally known for its physical stores, has significantly expanded its online presence and also facilitates both 1P and 3P sales through its platform, allowing customers to purchase directly from Walmart or from third-party sellers.
What is minimum advertised price?
Minimum Advertised Price (MAP) is a policy set by manufacturers dictating the lowest price a retailer can advertise certain products. While it doesn’t restrict the actual selling price, it ensures that the advertised price maintains brand value and profitability for retailers. MAP policies are crucial for preventing price wars among retailers and ensuring a level playing field, particularly in competitive environments like online marketplaces.
What is 1p vs 3p?
1P (first-party) vs 3P (third-party) refers to the different selling arrangements vendors have with online marketplaces. In a 1P relationship, the marketplace buys products directly from a brand or manufacturer and sells them to consumers, typically under the marketplace’s name. In contrast, 3P sellers list and sell their products directly to consumers on the marketplace platform, retaining control over pricing and inventory.
What is 1p vs 3p meaning?
The term ‘1P vs 3P’ represents the two primary models of selling on online platforms like Amazon. 1P, or first-party selling, involves the platform buying goods wholesale from a supplier and then selling them to customers, often with the platform managing logistics and customer service. 3P, or third-party selling, allows independent sellers to list their products on the platform, handling their own pricing, marketing, and inventory management, while the platform provides the infrastructure and audience.
What is amazon 1p vs 3p?
Amazon 1P refers to when Amazon itself purchases products from brands or manufacturers to sell directly to consumers, essentially acting as a retailer. In the Amazon 3P model, independent sellers use Amazon’s platform to list and sell their products directly to consumers, often utilizing Amazon’s Fulfillment by Amazon (FBA) service for logistics. Both models offer distinct advantages and challenges in terms of pricing control, logistics, and customer service responsibilities.
About the Author
Vijay Jacob is the founder and chief contributing writer for ProductScope AI focused on storytelling in AI and tech. You can follow him on X and LinkedIn, and ProductScope AI on X and on LinkedIn.
We’re also building a powerful AI Studio for Brands & Creators to sell smarter and faster with AI. With PS Studio you can generate AI Images, AI Videos, Chat and Automate repeat writing with AI Agents that can produce content in your voice and tone all in one place. If you sell on Amazon you can even optimize your Amazon Product Listings or get unique customer insights with PS Optimize.
🎁 Limited time Bonus: I put together an exclusive welcome gift called the “Formula,” which includes all of my free checklists (from SEO to Image Design to content creation at scale), including the top AI agents, and ways to scale your brand & content strategy today. Sign up free to get 200 PS Studio credits on us, and as a bonus, you will receive the “formula” via email as a thank you for your time.