How to Leave a Review on Etsy: Quick 3-Step Guide

by Vijay Jacob | Dec 11, 2024 | Ecommerce

how to leave a review on etsy

Understanding Etsy’s Review System: Your Complete Guide to Seller Feedback

Listen, as someone who’s been in the e-commerce game for years (and bought way too many handmade goodies on Etsy), I can tell you that leaving reviews isn’t just about venting or raving – it’s the lifeblood of the platform. Whether you’ve just snagged that perfect vintage lamp or commissioned a custom piece that blew your mind, knowing how to leave a review on Etsy is crucial for keeping the marketplace thriving.

Why Your Reviews Matter More Than You Think

Here’s the deal – Etsy isn’t just another Amazon clone. It’s a community of actual humans making, curating, and selling unique stuff. When you leave a review, you’re not just dropping stars into the void – you’re directly impacting someone’s small business. According to Etsy’s own data, shops with more positive reviews are 250% more likely to make sales. That’s huge!

And let’s be real – we all scope out those reviews before hitting “Buy Now.” I know I do. A whopping 93% of Etsy shoppers say they read reviews before making a purchase. Your honest feedback helps other buyers make informed decisions and gives sellers the feedback they need to keep crushing it. For tips on managing customer feedback effectively, check out this guide and explore why customer reviews are important.

Before You Jump Into Writing That Review

Okay, before you start typing away, there are some things you need to know about Etsy’s review eligibility requirements. First off, you need to have an actual Etsy account – sorry, guest shoppers, you’re out of luck on this one. If you checked out as a guest, you won’t be able to leave a review, no matter how much you loved (or didn’t love) your purchase.

Also, timing is everything. You can’t leave a review until after the estimated delivery date has passed. Even if your item arrives early (props to the speedy sellers!), you’ll need to wait until that original estimated delivery date. It’s just how Etsy rolls with their system. For insights on optimizing your listings, explore this resource.

Step-by-Step: How to Leave That Perfect Review

Finding Your Way to the Review Section

Let me walk you through this – it’s actually pretty straightforward once you know where to click. First, log into your Etsy account (you know, the one where you’ve been saving 47 items to your favorites). Head to the top right corner and click on “You” – it’s like your personal command center on Etsy.

From there, look for “Purchases and Reviews.” This is where all your buying history lives. If you’re on your phone, the Etsy app makes this super easy – just tap the “You” tab and then “Purchases.” Trust me, it’s way more intuitive than trying to navigate your tax returns. Need help with product photography? Check out these tips.

Writing a Review That Actually Helps

Now for the fun part – actually writing the review. Etsy uses a five-star rating system, but don’t just slap down some stars and bounce. The best reviews include specific details about your experience. Think about what you would want to know if you were the buyer.

Did that handmade sweater fit true to size? Was the vintage record player exactly as described? How was the packaging? These details matter. And here’s a pro tip: if you’re dealing with technical issues or having trouble finding where to leave your review, don’t panic. Etsy help is actually pretty solid, and you can always open a case if something’s really off. For more on photo editing, see this guide.

Timing Is Everything: The Review Window

Here’s something a lot of folks don’t realize – you’ve got a specific window to leave your review. Once that estimated delivery date hits, you’ve got 100 days to share your thoughts. Miss that window, and you’re out of luck. It’s like trying to get a slice of pizza at 4 AM in Manhattan – there’s a time and place for everything.

The system’s set up this way to make sure you have enough time to really test out your purchase. Whether it’s a piece of jewelry or a digital download, you get plenty of time to make sure everything’s kosher before dropping your review. For similar e-commerce platforms, learn how to shop on Shopify.

Adding Those Extra Details That Make Reviews Pop

Want to really make your review stand out? Etsy lets you add photos and even videos to your reviews. As someone who’s been burned by misleading product photos before, I can’t stress enough how helpful it is when buyers share their own pics. Just make sure they’re clear and well-lit – no one needs to see your artistic shadow photography skills here. For photo tips, see this article.

And remember, you’ve got a character limit to work with, but don’t let that stress you out. Focus on being clear and helpful rather than writing the next great American novel in your review. The key is finding that sweet spot between informative and concise. Also, check out this guide for photo sizing tips.

Step-by-Step Guide to Leaving an Etsy Review

Alright, let’s dive into the nitty-gritty of actually leaving that review on Etsy. Trust me, after helping countless ecommerce brands optimize their review systems, I’ve seen it all – and Etsy’s actually got one of the more straightforward processes out there. Let me walk you through it.

Accessing Your Purchase History

First things first – you’ve gotta find that order you want to review. Head over to Etsy.com and click on the “You” menu in the top right corner (it’s that little icon that probably has your profile picture or initial). From there, hit “Purchases and Reviews.” Boom – you’re looking at your shopping history.

If you’re on your phone (let’s be real, who isn’t these days?), the process is pretty much identical in the Etsy app. Just tap your profile icon and look for that “Purchases and Reviews” option. The mobile interface is actually pretty slick – sometimes I find it easier than desktop. If you’re interested in seller feedback, see this review app guide.

Writing Your Review

Here’s where the magic happens. Once you’ve found your order, you’ll see a “Leave a Review” button right next to it. Click that bad boy, and you’re off to the races. Etsy’s review system is built around a 5-star rating scale, and let me tell you – those stars matter more than you might think.

When writing your review, keep it real but keep it constructive. As someone who’s been on both sides of the review game, I can tell you that the most helpful reviews are the ones that give specific details about the product and the buying experience. Did that handmade sweater fit like a dream? Was the packaging Instagram-worthy? Spill the tea!

Pro tip: Etsy lets you upload photos with your review, and as a fellow New Yorker who’s dealt with plenty of online purchases, I can’t stress enough how valuable this feature is. A picture really is worth a thousand words, especially when you’re trying to show off that amazing craftsmanship (or point out any issues). For photo format conversions, see this guide.

Timing Your Review

Here’s something that trips up a lot of folks – you can’t just leave a review whenever you feel like it. Etsy has this whole system based around the estimated delivery date. Even if you got your artisanal coffee mug faster than expected (props to the seller!), you’ll need to wait until after the estimated delivery date to drop that review.

The review window opens right after the estimated delivery date hits and stays open for 100 days. Miss that window, and you’re out of luck – kinda like trying to get a slice of pizza at 4 AM in Manhattan. Actually, scratch that – the pizza’s probably easier to get. For a broader market perspective, explore the Amazon marketing guide.

Advanced Review Features

Adding Photos to Your Review

Let’s talk about making your review pop with some visual flair. Adding photos to your Etsy review is like adding toppings to your pizza – it just makes everything better. The platform lets you upload multiple images, and believe me, other buyers eat that stuff up.

Keep your photos clear and well-lit – nobody wants to see that awesome handmade necklace in what looks like witness protection program lighting. And hey, if you’re reviewing something that came with multiple pieces or variations, showing them all off can be super helpful for other shoppers. For comparisons with other tools, see this comparison.

Editing or Removing Reviews

Changed your mind about that review? No sweat. Etsy gives you 100 days from the estimated delivery date to edit or remove your review. Maybe that “just okay” product actually turned out to be amazing after you used it for a while, or vice versa. You’ve got options.

Here’s a little insider tip from someone who’s dealt with their fair share of technical issues: if you’re having trouble editing your review, try clearing your browser cache. It’s like the digital equivalent of turning it off and on again – works more often than you’d think. For more on editing, see this article.

One thing to keep in mind is that once a seller responds to your review, you can’t edit it anymore. It’s like hitting “reply all” on an email – there’s no taking it back after that. So make sure you’re happy with what you’ve written before the seller chimes in. Interested in apparel reviews? Check out this clothing guide.

Troubleshooting Common Review Issues

Technical Problems

Look, I’ve built enough tech products to know that sometimes things just don’t work the way they’re supposed to. If you’re hitting a wall trying to leave a review, there are a few common culprits. Browser compatibility issues are usually the first suspect – I’ve seen Chrome and Safari play nicer with Etsy than some other browsers.

Mobile app acting up? Try force-stopping the app and reopening it. If that doesn’t work, uninstall and reinstall it. Sometimes the app just needs a fresh start, kind of like how I need my morning coffee to function properly. For Shopify users, learn how to cancel Shopify.

Missing Review Options

Can’t find that “Leave a Review” button? First, double-check your order status. The review option won’t show up until after the estimated delivery date, even if you’re already sipping tea from your new handmade mug. If the delivery date has passed and you’re still not seeing it, it might be time to contact Etsy help.

Sometimes the issue is related to how you checked out. If you bought something as a guest (without logging in), you won’t be able to leave a review. It’s like trying to get into a speakeasy without knowing the password – ain’t gonna happen. For more on product photos, see this guide.

Impact of Reviews on Etsy Sellers

Let’s talk shop about how your reviews really impact Etsy sellers – and trust me, as someone who’s worked with countless ecommerce brands, I can tell you it’s huge. Your feedback isn’t just disappearing into the digital void; it’s actively shaping sellers’ businesses in ways you might not realize.

Seller Metrics and Why They Matter

Here’s the deal: when you leave a review on Etsy, you’re basically helping (or sometimes hurting) a seller’s visibility in search results. It’s like a digital version of word-of-mouth marketing on steroids. I’ve seen shops go from barely scraping by to crushing it just because they maintained a solid 5-star rating and got consistent reviews.

Think about it – when’s the last time you bought something online without checking the reviews first? Exactly. Etsy’s algorithm loves shops with good reviews, and they tend to show up higher in search results. It’s not just about stars either; the number of reviews matters too. A shop with 500 4.5-star reviews often outperforms one with 50 5-star reviews.

Legal and Policy Considerations When Leaving Reviews

Okay, before you go ham on that keyboard, there are some things you need to know about Etsy’s review policies. And no, they’re not just boring legal mumbo-jumbo – they’re actually pretty important if you want your review to stick and be helpful.

The Do’s and Don’ts of Etsy Reviews

First up, keep it real. Etsy has zero tolerance for fake reviews or what they call “review manipulation.” That means no reviewing your bestie’s shop just to help them out (I know, I know, but rules are rules). Also, stick to reviewing what you actually bought – seems obvious, but you’d be surprised how many people try to review things they just window-shopped.

If you’re having technical issues with leaving a review, don’t sweat it. Sometimes it’s as simple as clearing your cache or checking your estimated delivery date. But if you’re still stuck, Etsy help is just a click away. They’re usually pretty good about sorting these things out.

Maximizing Review Effectiveness

Want to write reviews that actually help other buyers and sellers? I’ve got some pro tips that’ll make your reviews stand out (in a good way). For insights on effective reviews, explore this Shopify guide.

Timing Is Everything

The sweet spot for leaving a review is usually after you’ve had enough time to really test out the product, but before you forget all the important details. For something like a digital download, a few days might be enough. For a piece of jewelry you’re wearing daily, maybe give it a week or two.

And here’s a little-known fact: if you miss the review window (which happens 100 days after your estimated delivery date), you’re out of luck. No exceptions. So if you’re planning to leave a review, set a reminder or do it while it’s fresh in your mind.

Review Management Tools and Features

Etsy’s got some pretty neat tools to help you manage your reviews, both as a buyer and seller. Let me break down the most useful ones.

Buyer Tools That Make Life Easier

The Etsy app is your friend here. It’ll send you notifications when it’s time to leave a review, and you can even save drafts if you’re not ready to post yet. Plus, if you need to open a case about an order, all your communication history is right there in one place.

Pro tip: use the “Purchases and Reviews” section in your account to keep track of what you’ve reviewed and what’s still pending. It’s like your personal review dashboard, and it makes life way easier when you’re juggling multiple purchases. For advanced photography tips, see this photography guide.

Final Thoughts on Etsy Reviews

Listen, I’ve been in the ecommerce game long enough to know that reviews can make or break a small business. When you leave a review on Etsy, you’re not just throwing words into the void – you’re actively participating in someone’s entrepreneurial journey.

Take it from someone who’s helped countless online businesses grow: your feedback matters more than you might think. Whether you’re dealing with technical issues or trying to figure out how to write a review on Etsy that’s actually helpful, remember that there’s a real person on the other end of that transaction.

And hey, if you run into problems or need to open a case, don’t ghost the seller – communication is key. Most Etsy sellers are passionate creators who genuinely want to make their customers happy. Give them a chance to make things right before dropping that one-star review bomb. For insights on customer impact, see this article.

The next time you’re about to leave a review, think about what you’d want to know if you were the buyer. Be honest, be fair, and most importantly, be human. Because at the end of the day, that’s what makes the Etsy community special – it’s not just another marketplace, it’s a community of real people making and sharing amazing things.

👉👉 Create Photos, Videos & Optimized Content in minutes 👈👈

Frequently Asked Questions

What is etsy review?

An Etsy review is a feedback mechanism that allows buyers to rate and comment on their purchase experience with a seller. Reviews are crucial for both buyers and sellers as they help build trust within the Etsy community. Buyers can leave a star rating from one to five and write a detailed comment about the product and service they received.

What is etsy open a case?

Opening a case on Etsy is a way for buyers to resolve issues directly with the seller if there are problems with an order, such as it not arriving or being significantly different from the description. To open a case, you need to go to your Etsy account, find your purchase under ‘Purchases and Reviews,’ and select the ‘Help with order’ option. This process encourages direct communication to solve the issue before Etsy steps in.

How to write a review on etsy?

To write a review on Etsy, go to your account and click on ‘Purchases and Reviews.’ Find the item you want to review, select the star rating, and write your comments in the provided text box. Be sure to submit your review within 100 days of the purchase date, as this is the time frame Etsy allows for submitting feedback.

How to review on etsy?

Reviewing on Etsy involves logging into your account and visiting the ‘Purchases and Reviews’ section. Locate the item you wish to provide feedback on, choose a star rating, and write a detailed review about your experience. Remember, your review helps other potential buyers make informed decisions and provides valuable feedback to the seller.

How do i leave a review on etsy?

Leaving a review on Etsy is simple: log into your account, navigate to ‘Purchases and Reviews,’ and find the order you want to review. Click on the star rating you wish to give and type your review in the text box. Make sure your review is submitted within 100 days from the purchase to ensure it can be posted.

About the Author

Vijay Jacob is the founder and chief contributing writer for ProductScope AI focused on storytelling in AI and tech. You can follow him on X and LinkedIn, and ProductScope AI on X and on LinkedIn.

We’re also building a powerful AI Studio for Brands & Creators to sell smarter and faster with AI. With PS Studio you can generate AI Images, AI Videos, Chat and Automate repeat writing with AI Agents that can produce content in your voice and tone all in one place. If you sell on Amazon you can even optimize your Amazon Product Listings or get unique customer insights with PS Optimize.

🎁 Limited time Bonus: I put together an exclusive welcome gift called the “Formula,” which includes all of my free checklists (from SEO to Image Design to content creation at scale), including the top AI agents, and ways to scale your brand & content strategy today. Sign up free to get 200 PS Studio credits on us, and as a bonus, you will receive the “formula” via email as a thank you for your time.